Tough Decision

Parsley decimated by a little green varmint

Parsley decimated by a little green varmint

No one in her right mind buys parsley plants. They are simply too easy to start from seed, right? Well, maybe not on a strip of land in north Texas, midst the USDA-designated “Grand Prairie,” where the soil is so alkaline as to resemble gray chalk. So I paid the price. It’s still cheaper than buying the cut parsley for $2.50 per recipe.

Like all my herbs, this one went into a clay pot full of beautiful store-bought loam. I watered and fertilized and Ms. Parsley promptly rewarded me with new, dark green leaves.

All sailed smoothly for a couple of weeks. Suddenly, the weather went all hot and dry, as spring in Texas is wont to do. I watered all the herbs but the parsley seemed particularly unhappy about it and began to turn yellow around the edges.

Investigating, I found two very large caterpillars making lunch of my investment. I knew their names immediately–Papilio polyxenes asterius (Stoll)–these were larvae with whom I had previously done business. The spiky green worms with black bands and yellow dots are the larvae stage of the black swallowtail butterfly.

The last time I planted parsley, the voracious consumers got the best of me and had completely defoliated the plants before I found them. I popped the chrysalises into a jar so I could see what emerged before deciding they were worthy of life.

Food or beauty?

Food or beauty?

How beautiful! Photos simply don’t capture the way sunlight makes the blue scales sparkle. I released the hatching butterflies, of course, and was glad I hadn’t squashed them out of existence in my irritation at losing my herbs.

This year the two worms are caught in the act and I have a decision to make. Do I want parsley or beauty?

Life is full of hard choices. Sometimes there isn’t a good way to go.

What do you think? Do I go buy another parsley plant before the garden center sells out? Or do I squash? Who lives–green plant or blue and black flutter-by varmint?

(Mature butterfly photograph from Wikipedia commons, by D. Gordon E. Robertson on this page:,_male,_Ottawa.jpg)


About janets123

Children's writer, newspaper columnist, essayist, poet, storyteller
This entry was posted in Short Takes on Life and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Tough Decision

  1. Mamasava says:

    My vote goes to that beautiful butterfly. It occurs to me that if an ugly creature had emerged, I’d be voting for the parsley!

  2. janets123 says:

    UPDATE: For those who are interested, I sort of indecisively decided to let the worms have their way with the parsley. It looked pale & sickly & after 2 days, I reneged on that and went out to halve their numbers. Lo and behold! Someone or thing had done it for me. Only one big stripy remained. Paler and sicklier 3 days more and I thought it was stupid to sacrifice the plant for a butterfly I’d likely never even view. Another inspection revealed, alas for insect lovers, no worms! The parsley is recovering now under cover of cloud and copious amounts of water. There is a little brown fence lizard living in the vicinity. I wonder what he eats…

  3. What a great article, and an awesome inspiration to watch the emerging butterfly! I did have a moment of sympathy for the parsley, though – it had never occurred to me how tough it must be to grow herbs in Texas, lol – so I’m glad if you were able to save it the second time around!

    • janets123 says:

      Thanks! Not all of Texas, just the particular strip of land I landed in. Glad something made lunch of my pests…so I didn’t have to. 😀 Happy you stopped by, fellow writer.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.